During her sister's bachelorette party, Bella visits a local psychic to get her fortune told. Surprisingly for Bella, the psychic tells her that she has already dated her future husband, and that if she doesn't marry him in the next year, she'll remain single forever. Following signs that come her way, Bella tracks down one of her exes, who has become a rock musician since their break-up.

Bella runs into her ex-boyfriend Jake, after he accidentally hits her in the head with a cup during the marathon he is running. He used to be a couch potato but now he's a fitness fanatic out to prove he's not lazy anymore. Back at home, Cyrus uses the "google" search engine and his friend's exes as a new drinking game.

Bella is reunited with ex-boyfriend Ronny after her apartment is robbed and he turns out to be the responding officer. Bella accepts a date with him to figure out if he's changed his ways or not. Back in their dating days, her father disapproved of Ronny because of his bad-boy image.

Bella runs into another one of her exes, Shane, a former vagabond surf bum. She wonders if he's grown up at all because that's the reason she dumped him.

Bella runs into her ex-boyfriend Josh. She broke up with him because he was a Momma's boy and wouldn't move out of her house. When Bella finds out that Mom is no longer an issue she begins seeing him again.

Bella runs into her ex-boyfriend, Steve, at her sister's rehearsal dinner. They dated as teenager while spending time at dude ranch, and Bella is anxious to see him and reconnect with him now.