Watch four thirtysomething friends, Jack "Gator" Gately, Tommy, Kate and Freddy trying to find love once again. Gator goes out on a blind date. Kate starts dating an NBA player, while Freddy goes out on a pricey date with the woman of his dreams.

Gator cannot stop thinking about his new girlfriend's minor flaws, leaving Tommy to take care of the situation. Freddy becomes friends with a bouncer, while Kate's musician boyfriend has a talent that is not what it seems.

Gator attempts to go back to his glory college years. Meanwhile Tommy accompanies Kate to a kid's birthday party.

Gator joins Kate in a boxing gym and he is dared by a woman in the boxing ring. Meanwhile Kate has to tell a naked truth to a co-worker. Freddy explains to Tommy the art of tantric sex.

Kate starts dating Gator's assistant. Freddy finds his ex in an online dating page and tries to reconnect with her. Tommy tries to find love in jury duty.

Gator goes out with a neighbor and animal-rights activist. Meanwhile Kate goes out with an exterminator. Tommy gives Freddy some driving lessons.