A scientist develops a pill to "ressurrect" some "dead" criminal men in Metropolis. Clark is jealous because a man who is trying to solve Mayson's murder shows interest on Lois, and she thinks he is attractive.

When Lisa gets lost at a Renaissance Faire, she meets a mysterious fortune teller offers to tell her about her future by reading her cards. We flash forward to 2010 at an Eastern university where she meets an arrogant proper young English gentleman named Hugh. They fall madly in love with each other, and Hugh proposes to Lisa. Lisa brings Hugh to Springfield so that he can meet the Simpson family. Hugh spends time with Bart and Homer, and it turns out to be a nightmare. On the day of the wedding, Hugh suggests that they go back to England and leave her family out of her life. Realizing that she has fallen in love with the wrong man, Lisa gives the engagement ring back to Hugh, and the wedding is called off. The fortune teller then vanishes in a puff of smoke and Lisa meets back up with Homer, appreciating him a little more than usual.