A shape-shifting warlock trick Prue into an unwanted wedding, with help from a high level priestess of the black arts. The priestess has her own motives, and turns all three sisters evil in an effort to claim The Book Of Shadows.

Mike becomes obsessed in hunting for a pig for his tribe but Jeff thinks that Mike's an idiot. At the Reward Challenge, Ogakor won by wining Fish Bait. Jerri, Amber & Mitchell went fishing and ended up catching fish for their tribe. At Kucha, everyone begins calling Rodger "Kentucky Joe". Rodger finds a heart shaped stone and gives it to Elisabeth so she can give it to her boyfriend back home. Jeff & Alicia make an alliance and add that Nick should not feel safe and that he's way too confident. Back at Ogakor, Jerri & Colby continue to get closer when Jerri spends the day massaging Colby's back. Keith becomes suspicious by there attraction and says he would vote out Colby. At Immunity, Maralyn keeps falling down which helps Kucha wins there 2nd straight Immunity. Keith asked Tina & Colby to vote with him to vote out Mitchell. At Tribal Council, Mitchell receives 1 vote, Jerri receives 1 vote, and Maralyn receives 5 votes and is voted out.

Rachel's agony over her 30th birthday starts everyone reminiscing about what they did upon reaching that milestone.

A bomb goes off in an office building killing one and injuring many more. The chief suspect is a security guard who left minutes before the explosion and has knowledge in bomb making. Nick helps his prostitute friend again. After giving in to his passion, she is found dead the next morning. Naturally, Nick is a suspect and to make it worse, Ecklie has the case.

Will is torn over ending his newfound relationship with Matt, a rising TV sportcaster who is extremely reluctant to let the world -- especially his macho business associates -- know about his sexual preference, so he continues to refer to Will as his 'brother.' Meanwhile as Grace does her best to help Will decide, Karen is livid when she discovers that he helped draft her husband's will, which will award much of his estate to charity.

Bishop Stewart returns, seeking pain medication from Luka, who also has his hands full dealing with the parents of a 16-year-old who does not want another heart transplant. Abby fills in as Carter's date for a Carter family function and sees her ex-husband there. Malucci treats a gay man who wants to contract HIV from his positive partner. Greene continues an abrupt personality change in the wake of his surgery. Weaver makes an appointment for a competency review for Mark.