Season 2 opens with Lebanon Levi leaning on a new soldier. Also: Esther returns to Lancaster, only to face unforeseen problems; and enforcer Wayne focuses on an issue with raw milk.

Ohio Mafia Boss Merlin recruits Alan to go after Lebanon Levi. Freeman and John are causing trouble in town, which Esther worries will affect her community standing. Jolin rejoins Levi's crew after a promise is made.

Merlin and Alan join forces to go after Levi's business. Jolin's authority is tested in Paradise. Big Steve is found and revenge is taken. Esther tries to make peace with Levi while Merlin and Wayne's friendship comes to an end.

Jolin and Levi plot to get rid of Freeman, Merlin goes to an Amish healing center in South Dakota, Alan turns to the bishop with information about Levi, Esther and Levi spend time together, and the Lancaster community starts denying Caleb Amish Aid payments.

Family alliances are put to the test as Esther has to choose between John and Levi. Alan has an audience with the Bishop in an attempt to dethrone Levi. When faced with the Church's retribution, Levi is forced to make a life-altering decision.

Levi tries to make amends with the Bishop by punishing one of his own; Alan goes to court to learn his fate; Merlin seals an alliance.

Never-before-seen footage and exclusive interviews show what really happened behind the scenes during this season's run of Amish Mafia. The group talks about its reaction to the show and reveals proof that the show is absolutely real.