Bonnie, Danny, Riley and Tucker are tired of Ben always passing Emma off on them every time something better comes along, so when Ben insists he can do it all by himself without their help, they go on strike. Without his support system, a frazzled Ben brings Emma along on his dates and his shift at the bar. Forced to rely on the very limited kindness of strangers, will Ben finally swallow his pride and admit how much he needs everyone? Bonnie and Danny take a cooking class with her idol, Tommy Kwan, but when Danny wins the chance to be Tommy's guest sous chef, Bonnie is determined to prove she's the better cook. Meanwhile, Tucker advises Riley to make up a fake boyfriend in order to fix her friendship with Danny.
Ben is a twentysomething man, who becomes a surprise dad to a baby girl when she's left on his doorstep by an ex-girlfriend. Ben decides to raise the baby with the help of his mother Bonnie, his brother Danny, his best buddy Tucker and his close friend, Riley, who is harboring a secret crush on him.