Miriam, Vonda, Barbie, Bates and Matthias-mulling a move to Brooklyn, where they will have to adjust to life in the city and wonder if they'll leave their rural communities forever.

The group set out for New York City, but some find the past may be hard to leave behind.

The group stay in a hostel on their first night in Brooklyn, and spend the next day exploring New York City, including Times Square.

The group visit Central Park and the Statue of Liberty to relax, but the mood is spoiled by an unexpected arrival. Meanwhile, Matthias mulls telling his wife about a recent transgression.

Miriam tells Matt's wife the truth about their hookup and the group deals with the fall out. Meanwhile, Bates works on launching his acting career and Vonda tries online dating.

The group decides to ditch their Amish clothes, but one of them goes missing. Miriam focuses on her dreams, Matt's marriage takes a drastic turn and Bates is blind-sided by his girlfriend back home.

Matt and Bates go home to salvage their relationships with the women they love, but Bates begins to realize it may be too late and that his real family may be in New York.

The Family is brought together by Miriam's return to New York, but not for long; Bates focuses on his acting career but misses his mother support.

Matt's spirits are high after his first live musical performance, but his mood changes after hearing shocking news from Venus. Meanwhile, Vonda starts to get over her late boyfriend; and Bates mulls a life-altering decision.

After returning home to face their new reality, the group struggles with their decisions to return Amish or stay in the English world.