Eli is free from his visions for the past six months after having an operation to remove his brain aneurysm. Nate experiences visions of his own suffering a similar fate as Eli that go along with the gift. Taylor is in a dilemma searching for her father.

Eli has his vision back with a beautiful brunette singing to him. The lady is Grace who turns out to be very much real and not just a vision after meeting her. Eli and Grace fall for each other. The same week Eli represents a father attempting to stop his son from receiving a military burial.

Jordan has a tough task of defending against charges of insanity. Eli is on a mission against lead paint manufacturers that may bring him before the Supreme Court.

In the aftermath of Jordan's case, the firm deals with the loss of clients. Eli attempts to convince Matt to stay with the firm, and then receives a vision that will prove critical to Maggie's upcoming wedding.

Eli and Jordon have problems with regular clientele and keeping up with costs with their new firm. Eli convinces Jim Cooper, a billionaire philanthropist, to lead the case on trial drug testing. Eli is put in a difficult situation when he learns Cooper's son wants no part in the trial. Meanwhile, Keith represents Patti's daughter. while Matt and Maggie work to to find the traitor amongst their midst.

Eli envisions himself within his father's body. Taylor has news to tell Matt about her pregnancy. Keith presumes the worst of Patti's daughter.

Eli and Keith have a difference of opinion regarding the innocence of their client. Eli begins to understand the bigger picture about his vision which affects his friendship with Patti. Dr. Chen does some matchmaking for Eli with one of his patients, while Maggie gives Matt advice on his relationship with Taylor.

While representing a Nobel Prize winner destined to find the secret of cold fusion in the future, Eli undergoes a dangerous procedure with Chen's rival acupuncturist to see if he has a future with Ashley Cardiff. Meanwhile, Taylor learns more than she wants to about her father while representing him in his divorce.

Eli searches for alternate dark methods to help him with his visions on Nathan's future. Keith and Eli defend a minister and Taylor and Matt find out about the health of their unborn child.

Eli, Maggie, Matt, and Taylor all end up working on the same case, in a small town called Sonoma. Eli and Maggie get much closer, but they end up having an argument.

While handling the Sonoma case, Eli and Maggie deal with the change in their relationship and Maggie meets a new man.

Eli becomes envious of Maggie and Paul's relationship, and to make things worse, they work together.

Eli is convinced that one of his friends will die in a plane crash he sees in a vision.