After Noah's unhappy encounter, Abel comes to his aid as the two struggle to find a way to keep their family safe. Forced to join the Mennonite Mob, Noah makes the decision to destroy it from within. At the same time, he must help a plane loaded with cocaine-packed cheese wheels land safely.
Noah Funk, a newly-elected Mennonite pastor, is determined to rid his community of drug traffickers by betraying a fellow Mennonite to the police. But instead of solving the problem, Noah's actions trigger an ultimatum from mob leader Eli Voss: in order to protect his family, he must get involved in the illegal operation. Noah decides that if he must work for the mob, he will secretly gather enough evidence to dismantle the organization...