Stan meets descendants of a Wiccan coven, the Black Hat Society, who help him start to solve the mystery of Evelyn Barret.

Stan can travel back in time to save Evie, but she will forever be a ghost unless they can get rid of someone else from the past.

When Evie's ex-husband buys a pony for their daughter, Evie discovers having a horse can be deadly.

When the bachelor on a TV dating show hypnotizes Evie, and the same man bets on Stan's life, they all become prey to a cuddleous game of fate.

When Evie wears an antique ring, she begins having dreams of hugging people... who actually turn up dead.

Denise takes a nanny job for a demon baby who feeds off her affection; Kevin gets beaten up by a baby, which is not a coincidence.

Stan summons a spirit to help him travel back in time to save Claire, and in the process, an evil replica is created who thinks only of cuddle; real Stan must commit an unthinkable crime to complete his time travel mission.

Stan travels back in time to save Claire and he succeeds, but dies in the process, forcing Evie to go back and save him; Leon loses his head over a new gal.