A snow storm traps Boyce and Lolli in the house with Stamps, Barton and Beyonce's cousin Nikki and tempers begin to flare.

After Boyce thinks that his congregation is dying off, Lolli and Nikki convince him to visit a church that features a younger crowd.

Boyce organizes a protest when Lolli is wrongfully accused of shoplifting at a fancy department store. Meanwhile, Stamps enlists Lester's help to get rid of his cupcake truck.

Lolli attempts to convince Boyce to sell some memorabilia on eBay, and it makes Boyce feel nostalgic. Barton helps out at a homeless shelter.

Boyce finds out that Nikki and her friends are planning a weekend trip without asking Lolli to join them.

Gooch is unhappy that Boyce is using stories about his life in sermons; Lolli receives a bad Yelp review.

After Nikki starts to wear out her welcome, Boyce and Lolli attempt to play matchmaker fir her.

Lolli delivers a sermon when neither Boyce nor Barton are available, and a positive reception from the congregation makes her want to do it again, much to Boyce's dismay. Meanwhile, Stamps is attracted to a single mom, but he has to meet her son before he can date her.

Nikki brings a dog to the office without permission, but Boyce thinks she's undermining his authority. Meanwhile, Barton's regular barbershop closes, so he starts hanging out at Lolli's salon; and Stamps gets a rude awakening at his new job.

Boyce attempts to keep out of the way after Lolli's mother pays a visit. Stamps wants to impress Kim and make her wish she had not broke up with him.

When Stamps gets sucked into a self-help philosophy called The Roar, Boyce crashes a seminar to see if it's legit. Lolli tries to get her salon on St. Louis Weekly's hot list, and Barton refuses to go to the dentist.

The church organizes a huge party for Boyce's anniversary as pastor but not everything goes to plan.