Casey digs into why she was rejected from CRU law school, while Calvin and Rebecca adjust to their new duties as presidents.

The KT's attempt to recruit new pledges, Tegan returns to help the ZBZ's maintain their top position.

Prepared to console his brother-less roommate, Rusty is met with a surprise when he finds that Dale is actually pledging a fraternity - and it's not Kappa Tau - which clearly affects their friendship. However, Rusty and Dana hatch a scheme to get his best friend back during a cuddle Mystery Party.

Beaver and most of the football team are caught plagiarizing their papers. Forced to write the report or fail the class, he turns to Casey for help, who is overwhelmed with her new classes. Beaver then introduces her to his "tutor" Dave, who sells papers and notes online. But the two fail to contact him, leading them on a journey to identify and find Dave.

Lasker Parkes, Peter's dad, comes to visit Kappa Tau, and Cappie feels pressure to impress the him. Cappie plans an Everest party for Homecoming, complete with ice luges throughout the house. Lasker wants to know who is Peter's big brother in the. Rusty wants to be Peter's big brother, but Peter wants Cappie. Meanwhile, Casey tries to convince Ashleigh to find a job and move out, but Ashleigh keeps dragging her feet.

Casey and Cappie find themselves facing a harsh reality after spontaneously spending the night together at the ZBZ house. Adding to Casey's personal sense of responsibility, Katherine confides in Casey about her own new romance and asks Casey's advice.

When the friends gather for Calvin's birthday, Casey and Ashleigh see each other for the first time since their fight, and Casey finds out that Ashleigh is dating Professor Segal. Meanwhile, Rebecca begins to wonder if she and Evan will make it through law school as a couple.

Casey and Evan continue their feud during a mock trial in Professor Segal's class, making the case personal instead of a simple class assignment; Rusty and Calvin must save Dale from being humiliated by the Omega Chis during the Pledge Talent Show.

When Rebecca finds out that ZBZ is up for the Golden Lily award for being the best chapter in the country, she recruits the help of former house president.

Set amidst the battle to save the Kappa Tau house, brotherhood and friendships are tested, while troubled and budding relationships will either be resolved or dissolved. Will Casey and Cappie face their futures together?