Red becomes furious when Eric scratches the Vista Cruiser. As punishment, Red takes away the car. Kelso who along with everyone else is tired of walking everywhere, borrows his cousins car. Not too long later, the guys end up in jail after the car is reported stolen.

Assistant Director Kersh tries to tear Scully and Mulder apart when he partners Scully with a New York agent investigating Alfred Fellig, a freelance police photographer who conveniently shows up to document the scene of a death as soon as it happens.

Junior is upset that Comley thanks Tony for returning the stolen goods to Comley Trucking, so he goes to visit Livia at Green Grove. However, Tony's mind is on Jackie Aprile who is in the hospital now and also feels guilty about Artie and Charmaine Bucco who are having to undergo a second arson investigation for the Vesuvio fire. Meanwhile, Meadow asks Christopher and Brendan for some help in studying for their SATs.