Stardate: 54775.4 Starfleet orders Voyager to retrieve a old space probe launched from Earth many years ago. When they find remnants of the probe on a radiation doomed planet, the also find survivors. They tell the away team the probe lead to the war that doomed their planet. The survivors demand that Voyager relocate them to a habitable planet before they will release the away team.

As Gale's delivery date approaches, the girls throw a baby shower for her... but it's an experience that throws Joey for a loop when she realizes it's possible that she could be pregnant, and Pacey is nowhere to be found. After many false alarms, Gail throws a baby name shower to try and think for a name for the baby, and the baby is born. While Dawson awaits the arrival of his new sibling, Dawson and Gretchen wonder what their future holds when Gretchen considers an out-of-town job... Meanwhile, Jack faces an unexpected situation when he learns that Tobey falls victim to a vicious crime.

AB pan-fries a chicken, also showing how to butcher it into perfect pieces.

President Bartlet goes to Oliver Babbish for advice on the potential ramifications of hiding his MS. Meanwhile, an oil spill near the Delaware coast spikes Sam's personal interest; Josh deals with a Mexican economic crisis, all while bickering with Donna; and Toby orders C.J. to get rid of a White House leak about a change in the President's position on school vouchers.

Stuart is hired to write a porno movie. Charlie and Caitlin compete for a donation from a wealthy male chauvinist. After Paul poses as the Mayor's son for a golf tournament, he becomes confused when the Mayor actually begins paying attention to him.

Tonight, Tom Green.