Lilith grieves over the death of her favorite lab rat while bar support Paul proves an unlikely target for a sexy seduction.

While sleeping, Harry is attacked. Audrey and Wheeler begin to have a relationship and Gordon Cole comes with a report saying Windom Earle helped work on Project Bluebook. Cole reinstates Cooper to the FBI and Earle plans to kill whoever wins Miss Twin Peaks. Donna sees Eileen visiting Ben and Gordon Cole believes Shelly will be able to cure his hearing loss. Annie recognizes the tattoos are coming from Owl Cave and after hearing of her terrible life, Cooper offers to help Annie. A petroglyph is uncovered in Owl Cave by Earle.

Jerry makes it so Elaine can have the apartment above him, but then tries to talk her out of it once he realizes the possible ramifications. Meanwhile, Kramer uses mousse in his hair, and George tries out the 'wedding band' theory in order to meet women.